When the CRA gets it wrong, small businesses pay: our resolution passed in Victoria
At the end of October, three of us from the Kamloops & District Chamber travelled to Victoria for the Canadian Chamber of Commerce AGM & Convention. We went with one main goal: to speak for local businesses on a problem many of you have told us about. Our resolution on CRA contact centres was debated on October 28 and passed, as amended. BC Chamber members had supported it back in June.
I'm glad about that. I also want to be clear about what it means, so here is the plain version.
Why we brought this forward
When you run a business, a call to the CRA is often how you check a rule before you act on it. You might be filing a return, handling payroll remittances or asking about a benefit. You need the answer to be right.
The Auditor General of Canada looked at how the CRA's contact centres perform and reported the results in October 2025. The findings were hard to ignore. Agents gave accurate answers to general business tax or benefits questions just over 54% of the time, and to general individual tax questions only 17% of the time. Only 18% of callers reached an agent within 15 minutes in 2024–25. The CRA's own target is 65%. The average wait for callers who chose to speak with an agent was 31 minutes.
Wrong advice can lead to reassessments, interest and penalties. Long waits take owners away from the work of running their business. Accountants also tell us they spend billable time walking call centre staff through tax rules, and clients end up paying for that time.
A fair look at the other side
The CRA does not fully accept the accuracy findings. At a House of Commons committee, the Secretary of State responsible for the CRA said the Auditor General's sample of 167 calls was small, and that the agency's own much larger sampling shows accuracy of about 90%. The agency has also said it will give accuracy more weight in how agents are evaluated and will bring in more standardized training and AI tools.
We take that seriously, and it's part of why our resolution is built around measurement. If the agency's numbers are right, public annual reporting will show it. If the Auditor General's numbers are closer to what businesses experience, public reporting will show that too. Either way, businesses and taxpayers deserve to see the data.
What the resolution asks for
As approved by delegates, the resolution asks the federal government to:
- Direct the CRA to carry out the Auditor General's recommendations, including quality checks that put accuracy and completeness first, and staffing that supports answering 65% of calls within 15 minutes.
- Enhance and expand the CRA's existing support services for tax professionals, building on current initiatives and pilot programs, so that they are easier to reach, faster, and more accurate and consistent.
- Strengthen ongoing training and professional development for contact centre staff, while using technology, including AI, to improve efficiency, accuracy and consistency.
- Set up data-driven accountability measures, including annual public reporting and protections for taxpayers and businesses that act on CRA advice.
Our original draft went further on two points. It called for a formal accreditation program for CRA phone staff, modelled on the ongoing professional development requirements for Chartered Professional Accountants, and for a dedicated phone line for tax professionals. Amendments from the floor changed those two recommendations, and the amended wording is what passed. It gives the CRA room to build on work it has already started.
Why this matters in Kamloops
Most businesses in our region are small. The owner is often the bookkeeper, HR department and the person on hold with the CRA. When the answer on the line is wrong or slow to arrive, it costs time and money a small business can least afford to lose. Clear, accurate answers also help owners comply, and that is good for them and for the CRA.
What happens next
Passing a resolution is a step, not the finish line. Adopted resolutions guide the Canadian Chamber's advocacy to the federal government. We can't promise a particular outcome, but we will keep the issue on the table and tell you what we hear.
If your business has had a good or bad experience reaching the CRA, we'd like to hear about it. Real examples make our case stronger. Send them to acacia@kamloopschamber.ca.
Thank you to Board President Alicia Glaicar and Director Alp Isin for representing our members in Victoria, and to everyone who supported this resolution, from BC Chamber members in June to delegates in Victoria.
Acacia Pangilinan
Executive Director, Kamloops & District Chamber of Commerce